Autocratic Despair: The Podcast

The Most Spatially Aware Man in France

• Nick Mortensen & Dr. Craig Johnson • Season 2 • Episode 25

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 31:13

France is on fire, and the most thoughtful Frenchman alive has thoughts.

Dr. Craig Johnson, UC Berkeley lecturer and PhD in Global Fascism Studies, opens at a seven. The days are getting shorter, the ennui is setting in (second week running for that word, a show record), and the thing driving his number is France’s slide into a youth uprising that the far right is, in his view, perfectly positioned to exploit.

For listeners who haven’t been following it, and most Americans haven’t, Nick and Craig lay out the story from the start. In mid-September, French high school students began blockading their own schools over teacher shortages, crumbling buildings and classrooms that don’t work. University students joined on October 1. Within a week it was teachers, parents and the trade unions, nationwide, and the grievances widened from schools to everything: the cost of living, fuel prices, wages, pensions. The Yellow Vests, the movement that shut France down over gas prices in 2018, came back to join the kids. The weekend before taping, around half a million people were in the streets. In Limoges, the nineteenth-century City Hall, a building that survived both world wars, was set on fire and its roof collapsed. In Paris, protesters pulled apart the base of the statue of Marianne, the symbol of the French Republic. There were eighteen hundred arrests in a single weekend, and the hardest number in the story is this one: by early October, French authorities reported more than five thousand arrests, the large majority of them minors, and Human Rights Watch has documented teenagers seriously injured by police munitions. The show treats that part with the seriousness it deserves.

Is it a psyop? Craig says no. He reads it as an earnest expression of the same thing happening to young people everywhere: an economy that has stopped working for them, aging populations, rising costs, falling wages, and a political system that seems to offer no way out. He places it alongside youth uprisings in Nepal and elsewhere, and explains, for American listeners, what the French word for suburbs actually means. The banlieues aren’t white-picket-fence neighborhoods. They’re dense high-rise communities on the commuter lines into Paris and Lyon, home to many of France’s non-white citizens and residents, chronically underinvested in and treated as a labor pool. He connects it to the French right’s long project of defining France as white and secular, and to the strange history in which the same right once insisted Algeria was simply France.

His worry is about what comes next. Youth explosions historically go one of two ways: they coalesce around a transformative demand, or they fizzle into disorder that becomes the justification for a right-wing crackdown. Without organization, leadership or concrete demands, Craig fears this one is headed for the second, with France’s presidential and legislative elections ahead and the National Rally waiting. He reaches for a Dead Kennedys lyric to make the point, which leads to the revelation that Nick, a child of the Thrasher-magazine era, thought all of that music sucked.

Nick’s contribution is to consult the most thoughtful Frenchman alive: Victor Wembanyama. For the non-basketball fans, Nick explains who Wemby is: twenty-two, from the suburbs of Paris, seven-foot-four, the number one pick in the 2023 draft, Rookie of the Year, an Olympic silver medalist, and the man who took the San Antonio Spurs to the NBA Finals this year. Nick’s case for trusting him starts with how he moves. A seven-footer who handles the ball like a guard and blocks shots from impossible angles has to know where every single thing in the room is at all times, which makes him, in Nick’s estimation, the most spatially aware person in France and possibly the world. Then there’s the crying. When Wemby wept on the court after big playoff wins, critics, including his own mentor Kevin Garnett, said he was too emotional. Wemby’s answer to a French reporter is one Nick calls a better read on masculinity than the entire manosphere has produced in a decade: it’s a fear of judgment, social codes, and he refuses to carry the burden of hiding his emotions. He also turns down sports-betting money, which in today’s NBA is almost unheard of.

So what does the most aware man in France say? That these are systemic inequalities, so deep-rooted that he’s glad young people are speaking up, that he hears them and supports them, and that he got out of that system only by luck. Nick is careful to note he said it before the fires and the mass arrests, and that supporting the kids isn’t endorsing what happened in Limoges. And Craig agrees with Wemby’s diagnosis, if not his optimism.

Nick holds at six and a half, and his driver is a story the show decided to defend when nobody else would: Katie Zacharia, Trump’s White House press secretary for exactly five days. Announced on a federal holiday, first briefing on Tuesday, out by Friday, felled by the revelation that the Pepperdine Law graduate who called herself a lawyer had never passed the bar. Nick’s contrarian take is that this was the dumbest scandal of the year. You don’t need to be a lawyer to be the press secretary. You need to be a liar, and she was both. She was set up to fail by a communications office that had no interest in helping the new hire, and, he argues, she was secretly the best press secretary in history: she ate an entire week of headlines in the same week federal agents searched a congresswoman’s home. Hit a grand slam in your first at-bat, then retire. And the administration that has sanctioned international judges and gone after law firms drew its line at disrespecting the bar exam.

Craig takes it somewhere sharper. This White House is a reality show, and people are hired for how they play on television. That’s the job. He quotes Werner Herzog, explaining why he watches professional wrestling: you must not avert your eyes. Craig can’t look away either, and on a show about authoritarian spectacle, that’s the most honest thing anyone can say. He calls it one of the best fifteen minutes of fascism he’s ever seen.

A comedy about fascism, a commedia for your particular brand of tragedy, and somehow genuinely fun. Stare into the abyss with friends.

Connect with us today!

Autocratic Despair is a comedy podcast about surviving American authoritarianism. Nick Mortensen is a comedian and father of three from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Dr. Craig Johnson holds a PhD in global fascism, lectures at UC Berkeley, and wrote How to Talk to Your Son About Fascism.

People on this episode