Autocratic Despair: The Podcast

Palmer Luckey is Doing a Dog Army

• Nick Mortensen & Dr. Craig Johnson • Season 2 • Episode 26

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 43:05

Some weeks the abyss stares back. This week it blinked. Dr. Craig Johnson, the UC Berkeley lecturer with a PhD in Global Fascism Studies, opens this episode of Autocratic Despair at a five, a full reset, the lowest number he’s ever given, and the reason is Brazil. Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva beat Flávio Bolsonaro in Sunday’s runoff to win a fourth term as president, becoming, by Craig’s account, the first candidate in Brazilian history to lose the first round and win the second. A month ago, after Flávio’s first-round win, the far right’s return in Brazil looked inevitable. The polls said so. Craig was choking up on air about it. And then it didn’t happen.

Craig walks new listeners through why that matters, with an American analogy that only works because Brazil’s actual history is stranger: Flávio is the son of former president Jair Bolsonaro, who is under house arrest after being convicted over a coup plot, and the Bolsonaros are the closest thing the Americas have to the Trumps, a right-wing authoritarian political family with a famous failson now promoted to the top of the list. He has the best moment from the final debate, when Flávio accused Lula of being the candidate criminals vote for, and Lula turned to the camera and addressed the elder Bolsonaro directly. And he explains who Lula is: a man who couldn’t go to school as a child because he was working, who lost a finger to an unsafe press in a metal factory, who taught himself to read, organized a union of metalworkers, and ran against a military dictatorship. Nick tells the story of Lula’s victory speech, where he took a minute to answer the Bolsonaros for years of calling him “Nine Fingers,” and made it about every worker who’s ever been hurt on a double shift.

Then Nick asks the question that keeps the show honest: is this just delaying the inevitable? Craig doesn’t pretend otherwise. The right won big in both houses of Brazil’s Congress. Lula can’t run again, and the left has no obvious heir. But he lands somewhere that’s worth hearing on a show built around despair. Lula’s win, alongside Péter Magyar’s defeat of Viktor Orbán in Hungary and the fall of Serbia’s strongman, is a direct refutation of fascism’s first lie: that it’s inevitable. The polls said it was over. It wasn’t. If you work, you can win. You might not. But you can.

Nick holds at a six, and his driver is a joke. Specifically, the joke the entire take-o-sphere made after Donald Trump spent a week of midterm rallies praising the body of Ohio Senator Jon Husted. In Youngstown he told the crowd he doesn’t do this with men very often. In Kentucky he described examining Husted’s backside, shoulders, hands, feet and jaw. In North Carolina, at a rally for a different candidate in a different state, he was still talking about it. He even credited his comments for Husted’s rising poll numbers. And everyone online had the same idea at once: is Trump the first gay president?

Nick’s answer is no, and he’s tired. The premise is decades old and built entirely out of stereotypes: the showtunes, the walk-up song, Studio 54, the gold everything, Roy Cohn. Using a closeted man who died of AIDS while denying it as evidence isn’t a joke about Trump. It’s a joke about gay people, wearing a Trump costume. And it does a second kind of damage. Calling Trump gay hands him a sexuality, a normal and healthy one, when the actual record about Trump and sex isn’t about orientation at all. It’s about consent: a jury found him liable for sexual abuse, he has bragged on tape about grabbing women, and this week a former Miss Switzerland told House investigators he raped her in 1993, an allegation the White House denies. Every time someone does the gay-president bit, that record gets pushed off the page. Craig takes the argument further, into the long and ugly history of falsely linking gay men with predation, a centuries-old prejudice masquerading as a goofy thing to say about the president, and argues that the joke only humanizes Trump while letting him flood the zone with the weird stuff instead of the serious stuff.

This week’s New Low comes from the Ohio governor’s race, where Republican Vivek Ramaswamy’s campaign produced an ad featuring the estranged mother of his opponent, Dr. Amy Acton, Ohio’s former public health director, calling her daughter a liar about her own childhood. A Toledo TV station checked the ad against police and court records and rated it false. The Republican governor of Ohio told him to take it down. The Vice President defended it, and the President called it pay dirt. Craig names it for what it is, victim blaming, and points out that surviving what Acton survived and building a life anyway is about as strong a qualification for public service as there is. The show plays this one straight. It deserved to be.

The episode closes with a startup. Warhound, a new company backed by the CIA’s venture arm, plans to clone the best military working dogs, gene-edit them for strength, endurance and smell, outfit them with battlefield AI gear, and rent them to the military by subscription. Canine-as-a-Service. Its partner is Palmer Luckey, and Nick introduces the man the Secretary of Defense just named to co-lead a 120-day study on the future of war: the teenager who built Oculus in his parents’ garage, sold it to Facebook for two billion dollars, was pushed out after funding a pro-Trump meme operation, and took the payout to start Anduril, a weapons company now valued at sixty-one billion. Craig, the show’s resident Tolkien expert, explains why naming a surveillance company after Sauron’s seeing stones and a weapons company after Aragorn’s sword is Silicon Valley in-group signaling, and why borrowing The Lord of the Rings for a tech-bro surveillance state is its own kind of crime. He has a theory about where the robot dogs came from, involving a video game where you fight Nazis. Nick has concerns about our robot program, a preference for dying at the hands of our robot overlords rather than an AI making a business decision, and one more: we already have dog armies. They’re called wolfpacks. And the real loss in a super-soldier dog is the thing that makes dogs great, the dog who hears thunder and comes to find you on the couch.

A comedy about fascism. A commedia for your particular brand of tragedy. Somehow, this week, genuinely fun, with more good news than this show usually gets to deliver about autocracy and authoritarian politics. Stare into the abyss with friends.


Names on the episode: Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, Flávio Bolsonaro, Jair Bolsonaro, Péter Magyar, Viktor Orbán, Aleksandar Vučić, Donald Trump, Jon Husted, Roy Cohn, Vivek Ramaswamy, Amy Acton, Donna Arthur, Mike DeWine, J.D. Vance, Palmer Luckey, Ben Lamm, Peter Thiel, Newt Gingrich, Elon Musk, Pete Hegseth.

Connect with us today!

Autocratic Despair is a comedy podcast about surviving American authoritarianism. Nick Mortensen is a comedian and father of three from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Dr. Craig Johnson holds a PhD in global fascism, lectures at UC Berkeley, and wrote How to Talk to Your Son About Fascism.

People on this episode