Autocratic Despair: The Podcast
Stare into the abyss of the United States' descent into Authoritarianism with a truly funny comedian from Green Bay, WI and a very serious PHD in Global Fascism Studies from Cal-Berkeley.
Very Funny. Very Serious.
Autocratic Despair: The Podcast
She’s Got Problems
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Some weeks the news is so dense that Nick and Craig never get past the numbers. This is one of those weeks, and the numbers are plenty.
Dr. Craig Johnson, UC Berkeley lecturer and PhD in Global Fascism Studies, comes in at a 7, driven by Midterm election jitters, and he delivers a Stalin joke that we will not spoil here, except to say that a historian of authoritarian regimes has very specific jokes available to him and he is not afraid to use them.
Nick’s number is driven by the firing of Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia. Sylvia spent thirty-two years in the Army, commanded the 101st Airborne, and holds a Purple Heart and six Bronze Stars, one for valor. For the past eleven months he ran strategy and planning on the Joint Staff, the office writing the long-term plan for the Iran war. Pete Hegseth fired him last week. The Pentagon accuses him of leaking classified information to reporters; he hasn’t been charged, other Pentagon sources dispute the account, and the evidence reached the press before it reached a courtroom. Nick explains the Joint Staff for anyone who’s never had to, asks why a government would try a general in the newspapers, and lingers on the moment the President, asked about Lieutenant General Sylvia, said “she’s got problems.” Four times. Nobody corrected him.
And then, because this is a comedy about the end of the republic and the hosts are both fathers of a certain age, an extended investigation into why kids today will wear sweatpants to absolutely anything, and what that says about all of us. The answer is not fascism. Probably.
A short one, and a fun one, from a show that stares into the abyss of autocracy with friends. The commedia for your particular brand of authoritarian tragedy.
Autocratic Despair is a comedy podcast about surviving American authoritarianism. Nick Mortensen is a comedian and father of three from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Dr. Craig Johnson holds a PhD in global fascism, lectures at UC Berkeley, and wrote How to Talk to Your Son About Fascism.
A reporter asked Trump about. Asked him, what about Lieutenant General Sylvia? Last name on it. And the president says, quote, she's got problems. She's gonna have big problems. Okay. Because Sylvia is a girl's name. And that was obviously the first that he'd heard about it. He said it four times. Nobody corrected him.
SPEAKER_01That is fascinating. Clearly, this means that this was some palace intrigue shit that was being kept from the king.
SPEAKER_00No need to complicate things by letting him know you fired a man, right? What's done is done? Yeah. Probably made more sense to him that a woman was leaking info to the media since they're all such blabbermouths, anyway. This is Autocratic Despair, the podcast. I'm Nick Mortensen, a comedian and father of three from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Each week on the Autocratic Despair Podcast, I stare into the abyss with my friend, Dr. Craig Johnson, PhD in global fascism, lecturer at the University of California, Berkeley, and the author of 2025's most important book, How to Talk to Your Son About Fascism.
unknownDr.
SPEAKER_00Craig, on a scale of one to ten, where would you rate your autocratic despair this week?
SPEAKER_01Well, we're recording this the day before the midterm election in the United States, so I'm back up at a seven. Everybody is expecting a democratic wave, but I remember sitting in those election watch parties November 2016 and being the guy who walks in the room and tells everybody to shut the fuck up. We need to turn CNN on and look at the Miami-Dade County results. That's the energy I bring to the party, and that's the energy I'm bringing today. I'm at a seven. What about you?
SPEAKER_00I'm at a seven this weekend's driven by the firing of Lieutenant General Brett Sylvian. His job was director for strategy, plans, and policy. J5 on the joint staff. Yes. Let me translate. The joint chiefs are the heads of each branch of the military. The army, plus the air force, plus the marines, plus the navy, plus the spaceforge, which does exist, and the National Guard. Four-star generals from every branch. J5 is the department that writes the strategy and the war plan. The one that takes what the president wants and turns it into a plan. Right now, that means Iran. Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia was coordinating the Iran battle plan. Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia had three stars when he was fired. Next up, if you do the job well, was a four-star in your own command. SETCOM, Indo-Pacific, that kind of thing. Crowning achievement for your military career. And we'd have been lucky to have Lieutenant General Brett Sylvia become a four-star counter. Absolutely. He served 32 years in the Army, commanded the 101st Airborne Unit until 2025. Undisputed American badass. Purple Heart, six bronze stars, one for Valorant.
SPEAKER_01Would he serve in Gulf War?
SPEAKER_00Yes. For the last 11 months, he's been the Pentagon's top military planner. J5, the director for strategy, plans, and pause. The guy who decides which tactics are going to guarantee our objective. And last week, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegzeth fired Brett Sylvia. Told the media he'd be referred to the DOJ for leaking classified information to the press about Iran, about Ukraine. No charges yet, but give the DOJ a couple of days. There's a lot going on. It looks like a slam duck. The Pentagon official told reporters that Brett Sylvia failed three polygraphs. Media outlet Asio says Brett Sylvia failed four, and that he admitted to doing it on video. Two other Pentagon sources dispute the whole thing. And here's my favorite part. The Pentagon's way of telling the world he leaked was to leak his polygraph results. Attorneys say they may have broken privacy law, but does privacy law really matter anymore? So the Trump administration leaked, then Brett Sylvia leaked. Yeah. Nobody's taken a polygraph about that one. Brett Sylvia is the second person Hagsath is fired from this exact Iran planning. But don't get the new guy up to speed quickly, I think. Hopefully he can think of an elegant exit, otherwise, there's gonna be more bombs. Last Thursday, a reporter asked Trump about. Asked him, what about Lieutenant General Sylvia, last name on it? And the president says, quote, she's got problems, she's gonna have big problems. Okay. Because Sylvia is a girl's name. And that was obviously the first that he'd heard about. He said it four times. Nobody corrected him.
SPEAKER_01That is fascinating. Clearly, this means that this was some palace intrigue shit that was being kept from the king.
SPEAKER_00No need to complicate things by letting him know you fired a man, right? What's done is done? Yeah. I just want to flag that for everyone. The commander-in-chief doesn't know who his top war planner is. For the war that we're currently fighting. Not even sure if it's a dude. If someone told him, then he didn't think it was important enough to store that memory. Tremendous problems, just incredible, really remarkable problems. Nobody's ever seen problems like this before. She should have just kept her mouth shut. 32 years on the job, and the boss doesn't have any idea whether you got a queen or not. That's cool. Progressive. I'd say that's a job well done. Yeah. Trump's got a lot on his plate, man, thinking up war shit for someone to implement, someone who knows how to keep his mouth shut. But Sylvia, for his part, admits only that he met with members of the media, but claims he didn't share any classified information or secrets with them. Talking to reporters about anything is bad if you're in the Trump administration. Yeah. And at the very least, they believe they've got Sylvia on the record as one of 20 officials cited in a story. They didn't say which story, but the Osun folks have deduced that it said military leaders were warning Hegzett that a plan to continue large-scale operations in Iran is unsustainable and weakening their ability to protect U.S. interests. And they weren't just pulling Pete Heges aside and mentioning that either. That's a formal diagnosis based on non-concurs in the classified Secretary of Defense orders book from the leaders of the Navy European Command, Indo-Pacific Command, and the Southern Command. The Pentagon spokesman called publishing that a crime. Take it for what it's worth. So here's what's bugging me. Lieutenant General Sylvia has not been charged with anything, Dr. Craig. The case was referred to the Justice Department just last week. No indictment, no court filing, no public evidence. Normally, if you think in general leaked secrets, you build the case, you charge him, and you prove it in court. But the Pentagon went another way. An unnamed official told reporters Sylvia had failed polygraph. The Joint Staff put out a statement wishing him well. And then they were made to walk it back when they discovered Sylvia had been referred to the DOJ. Then the internal reports showed up at Axios. Critics say Axios is a media organization that has cozied up to chomp this administration. And it certainly seems to be the case. They definitely don't want to draw any ire. They were the first ones to adopt the Gulf of America, if you'll remember. And they went ahead and published this piece, which smears Brett Sylvia as a criminal leaker without any charges from our Department of Justice, which, among other things, isn't really nice at all. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's a little mean. Totally rude. There are other examples of people in high positions being made to exit. Nearly two dozen generals, admirals, and senior military leaders have been fired, forced out, pushed to retire under Pete Hexit. Almost none of it has been publicly explained. What's it called when they do that, correct?
SPEAKER_01Firing all the generals and shit?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Name for that? There's a word for this. It's called a purge. Those aren't good, right? No, no, no, no. Those are bad. Yeah, the word leader most typically associated with purging military leaders is Joseph Stalin, not a famously nice guy, untactful, to use the phrases that we were using before. Not fun at parties. I do have a really good Stalin joke, though. Let's hear it. Okay, the Stalin joke is as follows. Joseph Stalin goes to the party congress in the Soviet Union and he's giving his speech to hundreds of party bureaucrats. Somebody in the audience sneezes in the middle of a sentence. Stalin looks at the crowd and says, Who sneezed? Everyone's afraid to say a word. And so he says, Guards. The guards run in and they machine gun the first row. They're all dead. Stalin says, Who sneezed? Again, silence. Everyone's afraid. He says, Guards, and the guards machine gun the second row. Finally, Stalin looks at the crowd and says, Who sneezed? And a frightened, wavering hand rises from the back rows and says, I did, Comrade Stalin. And Stalin looks at the men and says, Bless you, comrade. I saw it. Oh, of course. I mean, right. There is no possible end to that joke other than the end that it arrives at.
SPEAKER_00I'm not saying Sylvia didn't do it. I don't know. Neither do you. I will say that nothing this administration said should be taken as truth without investigation. They've earned that skepticism. That's kind of my point. The way you'd know is a trial, and they skipped right to where they smeared his name. Craig, what do you make of this? All these firings and the muddying of the water.
SPEAKER_01There's a lot of stuff going on here. This is an authoritarian who is shoring up power inside of the military. That's terrifying. That the president of the United States and or his allies are hangers on people operating in his name, like Pete Heggseth, that they think that they need to clean shop, that they need to make sure that the military is staffed only by yes men. That is bad news. Independent of the United States' desire to engage in enormous, costly, illegal, and morally bankrupt wars all around the world. Independent of that. It is bad for an authoritarian to think that he needs to make sure that the army's on his side, because that means that they're running some sort of calculation thinking about, well, we need to make sure that the army is on our side. That's bad. We don't want that. And then, of course, there's the strategic level. The people that have been training their entire lives in order to fight the kinds of wars that the United States fights. You're firing these men? Who do you want instead? Sylvia is already the guy you yacht as a replacement for the guy that you fired the last time. How deep is our bench? I don't know. This is bad news.
SPEAKER_00To shave 20% of generals off the four-star generals, they're not replacing them. No, which means that there's 20% less opportunity for a three-star general to move up. And all of a sudden, when you have a lot of applicants for less role, then you have to start setting yourself apart from all the other applicants. Traditionally, the way to do that has been by being very loyal to the regime. Yes. Offering to do their dirty work.
SPEAKER_01Yes. One of the big things going on here also is a continuation of how the Republicans have talked about the federal government since Reagan trying to run the government like it's a private business. We need to separate the wheat from the chaff. We need to reduce overhead, eliminate managerial positions. But the United States military is not a private business. It's a global spanning peace force slash military force. It's an organization totally unlike anything that the world has ever seen before. It's not the kind of thing where you want to be cutting managerial corners like this. It's fucking weird. It's strange.
SPEAKER_00I've gotten a lot of recommendations for new pants from people over the last few weeks.
SPEAKER_01Ooh, oh yeah, I'm so glad. We're doing a home improvement thing, and every time that I go into Home Depot, I'm like, maybe I should check out some of those pants, Nick seems to like so much. Are they there?
SPEAKER_00Have you seen those pants?
SPEAKER_01I have seen those pants. They look pretty comfortable. Currently, all of my all of my house shit is done in a pair of probably two nice jeans that I got from a thrift store, which are the least nice of my jeans. But since I'm not exactly a man's man, those are the most work-a-day jeans that I have. And the other work pants that I have are a pair of sweatpants that I inherited from my father 15 years ago. My father is six and a half feet tall and also a big guy. And the pants literally fall down around my ankles like I'm some sort of toddler going to pee. It's not exactly really useful for movement projects.
SPEAKER_00If you were a middle school girl though, you'd love to have those baggy sweatpants right now. That's true. The baggy sweatpants are really it. I have one pair of sweatpants I never wear. They sit in a drawer just in case I need them as pajama pants at some point. And I saw my 12-year-old daughter wearing them the other day. And she had friends over, so I didn't want to come down in her too harsh. I was like, you know I fart in those pants, right? They're sweatpants. I don't wash them. I put those on after I take a shower. Yeah. There's a lot of stuff going on in those pants, but you don't want to be touching with your legs whatsoever.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no. That's a kid wearing dad pants as fashion is a really surprising one to me. The kids love sweatpants. They think that sweatpants are sexy, which even as a millennial, that one's confounding to me. If you ask me to name the least sexy thing for me to wear possible, I would say sweatpants might be up there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but they're the easiest pants to get off. Maybe that's what they find to be a little sexy.
SPEAKER_01That is part of it. That is probably part of it. I see people work out in sweatpants, and I'm like, I understand as per the name that that is what they're for. But as a hot-blooded person, I can't stand it. I need to be cold. I need to be cold as much as humanly possible.
SPEAKER_00Stare into the abyss with friends, the autocratic despair podcast with Nick Mortenson and Dr. Craig Johnson. And don't forget Dr. Craig's other podcast, 15 minutes of fashion, available wherever you get your podcast.