Autocratic Despair: The Podcast
Stare into the abyss of the United States' descent into Authoritarianism with a truly funny comedian from Green Bay, WI and a very serious PHD in Global Fascism Studies from Cal-Berkeley.
Very Funny. Very Serious.
Autocratic Despair: The Podcast
Pete Hegseth: A Slow-Motion Decapitation Strike?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week Autocratic Despair does the thing it has been putting off for two years. Nick Mortensen and Dr. Craig Johnson finally contemplate Pete Hegseth.
First, the numbers. Dr. Craig, the UC Berkeley lecturer with a PhD in Global Fascism Studies, sits at a six, driven by the fight inside the Republican Party over who takes the wheel after Trump. He explains the Groypers, the movement around Nick Fuentes, the most influential open fascist in the country, and why he worries the party’s next generation is growing more radical even as Democrats win. Nick wonders whether Fuentes could have an Ebenezer Scrooge night and go straight. Craig suspects the path runs through the Catholic Church. Somebody get Pope Leo on the phone.
Nick is also at a six, driven by last week’s nationwide ground stop, when the FAA grounded every plane in the country for more than four hours. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy’s unzipped quarter-zip over a deep V-neck briefly reassured him. Then the administration blamed Joe Biden, Duffy took responsibility for what prior administrations gave him, and even the router company said its equipment worked as configured. Nick has seen this before: every episode of The Apprentice ended with someone fired for saying it wasn’t their fault.
The hosts also touch on Megyn Doyle, a former Turning Point USA chapter officer at Rutgers who alleges she was assaulted by fellow members at a TPUSA summit. Turning Point says its investigation found no sexual assault, and no one has been charged. Nick checks his own bias out loud, and Craig offers a frame from The Handmaid’s Tale.
Then the main event. The midterms, Nick argues, gave us a chance to look squarely at Pete Hegseth: not just the man, but how a weekend Fox & Friends host ended up running a war with Iran. Nick confesses he has never properly contemplated him. In his head, Hegseth is an inert substance who shows up every few months with a slideshow about warrior masculinity and then vanishes like smoke. He also has advice on Hegseth’s public pull-ups: step on a resistance band, my man.
The past two weeks made him impossible to ignore. The House fell seven votes short of advancing his impeachment. A sentinel at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier reprimanded his group on Veterans Day. And he posted “Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH SWORDS,” a line from the Roman general Pompey, who was later beheaded.
Nick lays out three doors: incompetence, a break from reality, or a slow-motion decapitation strike on our own military from the inside. Craig asks whether Hegseth peaks at Defense or is being built for something bigger, and explains why American wars have been won by logistics and morale, ice cream ships and turkey dinners at the front, not the Spartan toughness Hegseth sells. Nick’s conclusion: whichever door it is, the effect is the same, and scrutinizing the military isn’t disrespecting veterans. It’s how you protect the next ones. In January, Congress gets its chance to contemplate Pete Hegseth. Nick hopes they do better than he did.
Names dropped: Charlie Kirk, John Oliver, Megyn Doyle, Mark Bray, Justin Amash, Bill Kristol, Haley Stevens, Thomas Massie, Marco Rubio, Mike Waltz, Markwayne Mullin and Stephen Miller.
Autocratic Despair is a comedy podcast about surviving American authoritarianism. Nick Mortensen is a comedian and father of three from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Dr. Craig Johnson holds a PhD in global fascism, lectures at UC Berkeley, and wrote How to Talk to Your Son About Fascism.
A couple of likely yes votes were stuck in traffic. One was in surgery. Haley Stevens was cooking a French bread pizza in the toaster oven of the congressional break room. Didn't want to leave the toaster oven unattended.
SPEAKER_01Bad form in a workplace.
SPEAKER_00This is Autocratic Despair, the podcast. I'm Nick Mortensen, a comedian and father of three from Green Bay, Wisconsin. Each week on the Autocratic Despair Podcast, I stare into the abyss with my friend, Dr. Craig Johnson, PhD in global fascism, lecturer at the University of California, Berkeley, and the author of 2025's most important book, How to Talk to Your Son About Fascism. Dr. Craig, on a scale of 1 to 10, where would you rate your autocratic despair this week?
SPEAKER_01Well, Nick, this week I'm hovering around a six. That's about where I've been for a while. I honestly don't know what's gonna change where I'm at. Right now, I'm feeling pretty freaked out about what's going on inside of the Republican Party, specifically in fighting over who's gonna take the driver's seat, who's gonna get both hands on the wheel here behind the party. And it's pretty clear that the Grupers are making a bid for control of the Republican Party. That's terrifying.
SPEAKER_00Why do you say that?
SPEAKER_01The Gripers are a faction of the Republican Party and of the fascist movement in the United States broadly that's connected to Nick Fuentes, who is the most influential fascist in the United States these days. He's young, he is a self-identified incel, he's a self-identified extreme nationalist Catholic. He was a big hater of Charlie Kirk. Right after Kirk's assassination, there was a couple days where Fuentes was doing preemptive damage control because he was worried that one of his guys had shot Kirk, and that turned out not to be the case. Basically, what's happening now is that Fuentes is trying to get his supporters who call themselves Grupers, which is an old 4chan meme, Pepe the Frog shit. Somehow that's still around. Self-identified Grupers make up 30 to 40% of all staffers in the Republican Party, which means that a high percentage of the young men who work in the Republican Party aren't just people who listen to Fuentes' podcasts and streams and whatever. They personally identify with them. That's the political label they choose for themselves. Which means about half of all the staff people in all Republican offices in Washington, D.C. are just fascists. That's the future of the party. They got the momentum, they got the energy. What's happening is that Fuentes is being very clear about trying to get these guys to really take over the party, be the leading lights, which might mean losing in 28 but winning in 32.
SPEAKER_00Are there any legitimate front people, or do they have to persuade the current crop of front people, legitimate Republicans, to come over to their side?
SPEAKER_01That's the thing, is that it's too early for them to actually directly be controlling or influential. That's their problem. They're still too young. But that means that they might not win the factional control battle for the 2028 presidential election, or maybe not 2032, but they are the future of the party. And they sort of know that. The only way that they could not be the future of the party is if they all got kicked out. But then would they have left? This is what the young people in the party are. My fear, the fear that is metastasizing on me right now, is that over the next couple years, Democrats might do really great and like win quite a bit. But inside of the Republican Party will be growing an increasingly fascist new leadership in the party, who are all the kids that grew up when Donald Trump was the president and leader of the party, the kinds of politics that those people are gonna have and be open about, horrifying. Terrifying shit. That's what I'm afraid of.
SPEAKER_00Do you think that if Nick Fuentes had like an Ebenezer Scrooge evening where he just went through the whole thing? Yeah. We saw the ghost of Christmas future, what happens if they become fascist, goes back to the past, the whole bit, and had like a real introspective moment where he was like, I have the ability to control the attitudes of so many people that are going to be highly influential in the next couple years, and just went straight good.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow. What if he became a righteous man? Well,
SPEAKER_00who's that one guy that got shot that was super racist in the South and he got shot and then uh he was cool for a while?
SPEAKER_01Wallace. George Wallace. Weirder, I mean, George Wallace turning a leaf on segregation, that's the weirder political change, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Whenever you talk about George Wallace, any George Wallace, you're obligated to say and whatnot. You gotta throw an and whatnot in there.
SPEAKER_01You know, and whatnot. The clearest path to that for Fuentes is Catholicism. Because the Catholic Church is opposed to a whole bunch of the shit that he says. Except for the anti-abortion stuff and the anti-queer stuff.
SPEAKER_00Dude, Pope Leo is from Chicago.
SPEAKER_01It's true. For listeners, Fuentes is also a resident of the Chicago area, Naperville, I believe. Two Chicagoans, two American Chicagoans pushing international politics in weird, bizarre ways. Ugh, a good day to be Chicago.
SPEAKER_00Does anybody have a pipeline to Pope Leo where they can be like, hey, would you take a little interest in Nick Fuentes? Straighten him out a little bit.
SPEAKER_01Talk to this boy.
SPEAKER_00That would mean something.
SPEAKER_01What if he just entered the priesthood? Get him to join the Jesuits. What about your autocratic despair this week, Nick?
SPEAKER_00My current autocratic despair is probably six, just like yours. That whole airplane thing last week seemed iffy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. For
SPEAKER_00people that don't know, there's a major ground stop towards the end of last week. Here's what a ground stop is it's when the FAA, the Federal Aviation Administration, tells planes they can't take off. Usually it's just from one airport. There's a storm in Chicago, a problem in Atlanta. Last week it was every airport in the country, every plane in America grounded for more than four hours. That almost never happened.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00Happened on September 11th when they made all the planes stop for two days. And any flights in the air, when it was announced, had to land at the nearest airport, but they did that for good reason. Any of those flights could have been hijacked. Last week was a big deal. Thousands of flights were canceled. Nearly 2,300 on Sunday alone. Hundreds of thousands of people stuck. People hunting for their luggage for hours. NFL referees driving from a noon kickoff game in Indianapolis to make it to Pittsburgh for a 7 p.m. game. I wasn't flying with it happened, so I'm not particularly aggrieved by it, but I got my eye on it. People are gonna be traveling for the holidays this week and next, and my wife is flying in December to run a marathon with her, which is lovely, and reminds me that I should get some trip insurance on her for her. I mean makes sense from an economic standpoint. I wasn't terribly surprised by all this. I watched a John Oliver piece on air traffic control a while back, and the whole impression I came away with was that the system was gonna collapse one way or the other sooner or later. It's actually surprising it hadn't collapsed yet. On Friday, when it went down, I didn't think how could they let this happen? I thought, well, here it is, and had a little bit of concern that it might have been a hack from Iran. I'd heard about a bunch of grocery freezers in Europe being turned off and causing a bunch of food to spoil.
SPEAKER_01I thought about this too. I thought about this too. A
SPEAKER_00bunch of bomb threats were being called in over Europe over the last few weeks. It turns out it wasn't any cyber attack. I was relieved when they trotted out old Sean Duffy, the Secretary of Transportation, and Duffy was rocking a deep V.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's true. He was
SPEAKER_00that deep V was there to reassure people that he was in his pajamas when he heard about this and he rushed right into the office. So all he had was this deep V and this Department of the Interior quarter zip, which he didn't zip even a little bit of the way.
SPEAKER_01That wasn't even a quarter zipped, no.
SPEAKER_00It just didn't seem like an emergency because he didn't even bother to zip up. In an emergency, you gotta hide your clavicles.
SPEAKER_01Literally not a buttoned-up guy.
SPEAKER_00This is a serious situation, not so serious that Duffy needed to get out of deep V mode. I was curious as to whether that was an affectation to give me a false sense of confidence, or the love letter from one man to the deep V. You see, I know a little bit about Sean Duffy. He's from Wisconsin, after all. And he was in a season of Road Rules a long time ago. I feel like I've taken measure of the man. And he doesn't strike me as the type to wear a deep V in emergency circumstances. At least not without a purpose, anyway. I heard it was an IT problem. They were talking about copper cable getting replaced by fiber optic cable, like it was analog to digital transformation. But I kind of remember that I had a cable modem not that long ago, and it was really good for getting digital information from one computer to another. So that didn't quite add up.
SPEAKER_01No. And
SPEAKER_00I kind of figured the whole thing was just the airline industry taking its medicine to update their system and it getting a little fucked up. That's a big project. I'm not gonna get too upset about it in those circumstances. I didn't want to happen, of course, but at least it's an error of commission and not an error of omission.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00And besides, Duffy had some deep V energy about it. So lamentable, but we're headed in the right direction. Onward and upward, air travel infrastructure-wise, individual planes,
SPEAKER_01not particularly. No, those are those are mostly sitting and waiting.
SPEAKER_00Then I watched an interview with Mark Wayne Mullet, head of Department of Homeland Security, who was not wearing any sort of V-neck at all, much less a deep V. And I got a little nervous. All these guys had to do was let us know that they were making moves. This was a lamentable screw-up, but there's bound to be a learning curve as they integrate AI into a system that was literally using the equivalent of an abacus. And these guys took a different approach instead. By the Sunday morning shows, they were full-on blaming Joe Biden. Duffy claiming that the Biden administration was an FAA disaster and that he only had so much money in the budget to fix it, but if he had 50 billion more, he'd have this thing humming in a couple days, no problem. They tried to pin Duffy down on this, and he was pretty slick about it, saying that he took full responsibility for what was given to him by prior administration. Which is a classic, I'm sorry if it hurt your feelings if there ever was one.
SPEAKER_01That's impressive.
SPEAKER_00It was beautiful. If you really think about it, there was no way this would have happened if all of history hadn't played out exactly as it did. Somehow it worked on me a little. The investigation is looking at whether some routers in the data system had their ability to broadcast data turned off. They kind of had it pinpointed there. The company that makes the routers put out a statement saying the routers functioned as configured by the installer. You know, the error was definitely not in our equipment. It was in the people. So even the routers are passing the blend.
SPEAKER_01That's definitely passing the buck. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's when I went throw it on the pile because they have trained my brain. So when I hear Biden left the cupboards empty, I know exactly what it means. It means it was our fuck up. It just wasn't only our fuck up.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's probably true. The system is really old. Yeah. People have been warning about it for years. Both parties let it rot. I'll give them that one. But you lose the right to say it when you spent 10 years hammering everybody else for their incidental fuck-ups. Yeah. When a plane went down over the Potomac in January of last year, the president stood at a podium within a day and blamed diversity hiring at the FAA. Nobody on the Democrat side of the aisle ever says it was the last guy's fault, because they know exactly what that sounds like. It sounds like they're being a bunch of limp dead motherfuckers. I realize that I've seen this before. Every episode of The Apprentice built to the same scene, the boardroom, where something went wrong, and everybody at fault tries to pass the blame on to someone else. And the one with the weakest excuse got fired. Donald Trump spent 14 seasons firing people for saying it wasn't my fault. Now, that's his whole administration's answer to everything. That's always been my problem with Trump and the Trump people. It's not that they make mistakes. Everybody makes mistakes. It's that they accept from themselves the kind of conduct and behavior they'd crucify anybody else
SPEAKER_01for. If
SPEAKER_00Sean Duffy had said that in the boardroom, he'd be gone before the commercial. I met with Andy last week and we were trying to come up with things. He really wants us to cover that turning point USA thing. I got nothing. I got nothing except how friend-zoned are you when you're carrying her period products.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if that was the girl that had the thing happen to him that did the read of the accusations on TikTok. I don't know if that was Megan Doyle herself or not.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't remember either.
SPEAKER_00Whoever did it did a shitty job of reading from the screen. So it didn't feel like a legitimate accusation to me in any way, shape, or form. Then I was like, well, how much of that is me saying, fuck this bitch. She's in turning point USA, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, I know that's wrong, but there's a part of me that has strong bias against all these fucking people. Of course you're gonna get raped. You walked into the belly of the beast. This is inevitable.
SPEAKER_01It is an aspect of it. I had also sort of intentionally ignored that aspect of it because I was like, well, there isn't really anything to say about this other than like, why would you associate with these people? And at the same time, this person is the victim of sexual assault. And also, this is an organization that explicitly intentionally defends people who are rapists. That's what it does.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. There's okay, how much do you really believe all women if you're batting an eye over this one? Yeah. I'm not obligated to believe all women. I believe all the ones that seem remotely credible. If somebody's walking around looking like a crazy person and saying that she was raped by George Washington, I'm probably not gonna believe her.
SPEAKER_01No,
SPEAKER_00I think that's reasonable. But as the situations become more plausible, I think anyone that's remotely plausible, I'm just gonna err on the side of believing. Oh,
SPEAKER_01yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because I'd rather err on that side than on the other side. The other side is more severe.
SPEAKER_01I believe this person, certainly. TP USA fucking sucks. And if that's the takeaway, then it's like, well, yeah, this isn't exactly new information, you know.
SPEAKER_00There's supposed to be a video of what happened, and it doesn't sound like it was a sexual assault. It sounded like it was an assault by someone of the opposite sex that like jumped on her and pinned her down on a bed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if anybody was fumbling after clothes, trying to get them, you know. I don't know if this was like the beginning of a rape or it was just like a
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a complicated one. Cause like
SPEAKER_00it's whatever I guess the person infers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00The true definition of assault is making someone afraid for their bodily safety. So it was definitely assault. I don't think I care to split hairs about whether it was sexual in nature or not. There's a lot to suggest. Any violence against women sexual in nature? Probably all of it on some level.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. That would be one of the things is okay, so it's a man taking control of a woman's body. Clearly, gender and sex are involved there.
SPEAKER_00But also, she's definitely on her period, and everybody knows that. I don't know if that plays into your concept of whether you should rape a girl in front of your friends from Turning Point USA, whether she's having her period or not. I think it would. This is a crime of violence and control. I don't know. I just don't know. Here's the other thing about Megan Doyle. You know that guy from Rockers that had to leave the country because he wrote the book about anti-fascists?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00She was the chapter head from TP USA that went after him. Oh,
SPEAKER_01really?
SPEAKER_00She was the face of that.
SPEAKER_01Oh my god. My read on this has always been this is essentially of Fred from The Handmaid's Tale. This is a woman who participated in a male supremacist movement and then became herself a victim of that violence. Her having been subjected to that violence isn't something we should celebrate. And at the same time, I think that it is important to us to recognize that it is not surprising that these men would behave this way, even or maybe especially towards a woman that they supposedly are working with. That's a feature of who they are and what they are, part of what they believe that they should be able to do these things.
SPEAKER_00Here's the other aspect of it. These turning point USA events are fuckfest. Yeah. I think you kind of show up there expecting there to be some sort of loose morality situation when you're so good all the time. Did I ever tell you about what the orgy scene is like at a marathon, especially if the marathon is on a Saturday?
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, that makes sense though.
SPEAKER_00It's a bunch of uptight, super disciplined people training for something, and then they finally have the opportunity to cut loose. It's all people in good shape and they're all high on endorphins. Shit happens. You don't want to be on that floor when you're renting a hotel room necessarily.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. You
SPEAKER_00don't want to be there unless you know what's going to happen.
SPEAKER_01Any conference is a place where people hook up. That's simply the case.
SPEAKER_00But I would think that would be part of the allure of the turning, because like those people suck. There's got to be some pussy in it for for those guys. You know, like a lot of those guys seem like relatively cool. It's like their identity because it's just a way to pull chicks.
SPEAKER_01I think for some of them it is. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Turning point USA could be a pretty cool deal. If there was some Christian organization that was on the up and up, really doing good work.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. And earnestly, the whole Christian movement among US youth, that would be fucking crazy. If it was, okay, well, we have a we're youth and we're promoting a form of Christianity that's actually following the things that Christ talks about, like justice and honoring the poor and tending to the sick and prisoners and all that sort of stuff. That'd be fucking incredible. But no, you know, we get the other form of Christianity.
SPEAKER_00Dr. Craig, now that the smoke has cleared on the midterms a bit, I think the midterms gave us a gift. They've given us a new vantage point. Our heads are finally above water in the metaphorical sense. It's still gonna be quite an effort to swim to shore, and whether we can do so, that remains to be seen. But because of the midterms, we're at least able to orient ourselves towards the shores. But if we're ever gonna make it to safety, we need to address reality head-on, which is no easy task, because while things have gotten pretty far down the line, we've finally been given the chance to contemplate Pete Hegseth.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Not just the man Pete Hegseth, the meaning of Pete Hegseth, the reality in which a Pete Hegseth type is allowed to exist, the circumstances that have allowed Pete Hegseth to thrive, and the decisions we made as a country that let him become a character that we actually have to consider.
SPEAKER_01You're absolutely right. Prior to the midterms, it was just piled higher and deeper, one thing after another. So then it's like, oh, okay, a guy from Fox and Friends is now the head of the most powerful military in the history of the world. Okay, fine. I guess 15 minutes later there's gonna be some other crazy shit that I need to deal with. You just forget about it, you ignore it, but
SPEAKER_00I'll get to Pete Heggseth when I can find the time.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Yeah, when am I gonna get to this?
SPEAKER_00When the deluge is over. I think that we need to recognize this opportunity because I gotta confess something. I have never properly contemplated Pete Heggseth. Not in two years, not once.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00I know he's there, I know what his job is, but the file on Pete Heggseth in my mind is still C-list MAGA celebrity, weekend propaganda TV host with almost zero self-awareness that is in way over his head. The only updates I've made to the Pete Hegseth file in my mind over the last two years, since he was confirmed as Secretary of Defense, have been is an unrepentant dickhead who always seems to be wearing fun socks and lines his suits with the US flag so you know he's a true patriot. I've always treated him like an inert substance, an unserious character surrounded by serious characters who probably won't let him fuck up his job. Who comes out of the blue every couple months, runs through a well-produced slideshow about the masculinity of our war fighters with the Apple developer conference energy, reminds us he's still an unrepentant dickhead, and then disappears like a plume of smoke.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Which of course is not true. Pete Hegseth is one of the most dangerous men on earth. He's in charge of a war effort. He went to Princeton. I can't even comfort myself by focusing on how dumb he is. I think I avoid thinking about Pete Hegseth for the same reason I avoid thinking about my own mortality. It gives me profound anxiety. Because when I look at him, I see the saddest guy around. Everything about him looks like a man terrified of not being enough. A whole life full of chasing status symbols, external validation, only ever operating in places where somebody's grading him. And I get sad for that dude because I know what that life was like. I was a comedian. Instant feedback. You always know if you're on the right track or not. And when the answer is in the affirmative, when you get big laughs on stage, you're absolute world beater. Life's great. But you can kind of become an asshole. But when you bomb a set, it turns into an existential crisis, at least until your next set. Nobody without a deep dark hole inside themselves wants to build that kind of life. It's two high stakes. It runs contrary to my concept of what being a man should be, and it makes them so sad that I have to hate him in order to move past that feeling.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So many of the people that I have genuine animosity toward in this life are people that suffer from the same shortcomings and maladies as I do. Only instead of working on that aspect of themselves, they embrace it as central to who they are and somehow become successful because of it. So I feel a sense of rage when I think about Pete Hagseth, and it makes me want to stop thinking about Pete Hagseth. I have never come to grips with the fact that Pete Hagseth is our Secretary of Defense. And I've appreciated that he's allowed me to do so by not popping up on my radar as much as he probably should, usually only to offer me a quick reminder that he's an unrepentant dickhead who thinks about masculinity far too often for someone incapable of executing a single pull-up with proper form, yet so hellbent on doing pull-ups in public.
SPEAKER_01That's a really bizarre aspect of it. If you're going to be this macho dude who claims to be so macho and powerful and strong and effective, you should at least be able to do one good clean bench press. But the guy can't.
SPEAKER_00It's not hard.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00Step on a resistance band, my man. You're doing enough pull-ups. I got no doubt about it. You'll get there. Whatever shame you have about doing an assisted pull-up is nothing compared to the shame you ought to feel over doing pull-ups like that. Six months tops. And then he's doing those CrossFit pull-ups, you know, the ones where you pull up and then you flip your wrist and you go up over the thing like you're getting out of a pool.
SPEAKER_01A muscle up.
SPEAKER_00But yet he opts for those pull-ups. Hard to fault a guy for not building the right battle plan for the Middle East when he can't even figure out a six month plan to finally do a proper form pull up. This is the kind of trifle that is all I can be bothered to think about when it comes to Pete Heggseth, because truly I have never properly considered Pete Hegseth. So believe me when I tell you that if there were any way To avoid contemplating Pete Hegseth, I'd have found a way to do just that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But contemplate Pete Hegseth, we must, so contemplate Pete Hegseth, we shall.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Now
SPEAKER_00let's level set here. Pete Hegseth is our Secretary of Defense currently, right now, as we engage in a prolonged military engagement with Iran that isn't going so well and costing people that pay taxes about $1.65 per day, every day. Just short of $50 a month. For going on almost a year now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it has no reason to stop. Now that Trump has tanked the economy intentionally here, because it's primarily because of oil tankers and their inability to get to and from places in the Middle East to the rest of the world, that's what's going on. Now that Trump has tanked the economy with the war in Iran, and now that that's cost him the midterms, because that's probably the proximate reason that the Republicans lost so bad. Now that that's happened and there's not an election for two years, Trump has no fucking reason to resolve this war anytime soon. So as long as Hageth is the head of the DOD while this war is happening, and as long as this war keeps happening, because it's gonna happen for a while, he's gonna still be here being in charge of the military during a war.
SPEAKER_00There is no end in sight for this conflict, which we're not winning by even the most generous or delusional assessments.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00Nobody seems to be blaming him for that, which is super duper odd considering he's in charge of the military. Yeah. At least that's what the org chart says. It's been a big couple of weeks for Pete Heggseth, Secretary of Defense. Congress tried to impeach him, and he was sweating it. Yeah. Did his first press conference in months to tell Congress to go fuck themselves. None of the shit he did was wrong, and even if it was wrong, he'd do it again because that's what Donald Trump wanted. It's not illegal if the president wants you to do it. Just ask the Supreme Court. Probably right.
SPEAKER_01That's probably true.
SPEAKER_00He missed out on being impeached by seven votes, which was a procedural issue on an awkwardly scheduled vote that everyone knew about. A couple of likely yes votes were stuck in traffic. One was in surgery. Haley Stevens was cooking a French red pizza in the toaster oven of the congressional break room. Didn't want to leave the toaster oven unattended.
SPEAKER_01Bad form in the workplace.
SPEAKER_00Couple were at a party thrown by elect Democratic women, which is a pass-through for you guessed it, APAT. They held that vote at 5 30. Those guys were at the party. They couldn't get back in time. Pete Hexath got a little cocky after they failed to impeach him last week. The next day, his group got yelled at by the guard at the tomb of the unknown soldier for whooping it up.
SPEAKER_01Oh my god, I forgot about this, Nick.
SPEAKER_00He looked like a dick and he knew it. He agreed it wasn't cool, but he didn't think anyone make a big deal about it because it was Veterans Day, man. And
SPEAKER_01he's a veteran.
SPEAKER_00Say what you will about the unknown soldier. He was no veteran.
SPEAKER_01Well, we don't know, you know.
SPEAKER_00On Saturday night, Pete Heggseth went even harder. He tweeted out a badass retweet to a video of Secretary of State Marco Rubio announcing that the United States does not recognize the Internal Court's jurisdiction since they don't have any enforcement mechanism and have to rely on the consent of countries to their authority. Added the money quote, stop quoting laws to men with swords.
SPEAKER_01Jesus Christ, man. I'm also suffering from Pete Hague stuff blindness. You're gonna have to explain this one to me. What the fuck's going on here?
SPEAKER_00During Rome's civil wars in the first century BCE, the citizens of Massana, Sicily, protested Pompey's military actions by citing an ancient Roman legal charter that exempted their city from his authority. Pompeii allegedly dismissed their legal arguments by saying, Stop quoting laws to us, we carry swords, which is commonly paraphrased as stop quoting laws to men with swords. That's the origin of Hexess's sweep. It sparked controversy because Pete Hexess is the civilian head of the US military. Critics across the political spectrum argued that using the quote without full context sounded like an endorsement of unchecked military force over the rule of law.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it only sounds like that. That's right. Sure. It just sounds like it. That's all.
SPEAKER_00Former libertarian congressional rep Justin Amash wrote that rejecting the International Criminal Court's jurisdiction is one thing. Declaring that laws become irrelevant the moment swords appear is another. That's his might makes right said otherwise. Conservative commentators and critics like Bill Kristol similarly argued that in a constitutional republic, the military, or the sword, is strictly subordinate to the law, and noted the historical irony that Pompey's dismissal of legal norms contributed to the collapse of the Roman Republic and his own eventual assassination. Supporters of Heggseth framed the post strictly as a blunt realist rebuke to unelected international bodies trying to persecute U.S. troops and leaders under treaties the US never ratified. And that quote applies to Heggseth's week, too. Pete Heggseth had one of the worst Mondays that anybody's ever had last week. Garfield included.
SPEAKER_01By the end of the week, he was sitting pretty.
SPEAKER_00Wasn't gonna let people trying to inflict the Constitution on him get him down. Truly, nothing could break the stride of Peter Bryan Hegeseth last week. He was never gonna get impeached and removed by this Congress anyway. This was all more or less a political stunt by Thomas Massey from Kentucky to appear as though he was going down swinging as a last true respecter of the Constitution within the Republican Party, so he can run for president in 2020. But the next Congress could impeach Hegeseth pretty easily. He might find himself out on his ass if the next Senate votes two-thirds to remove him, which is unlikely. But it might happen. It may turn out that Trump needs to make a blood sacrifice to keep this show going.
SPEAKER_01That's entirely possible. If part of what's going on is Trump feeling around for who's going to be the sacrificial lamb, it might be Hegseth.
SPEAKER_00Tossing noted unrepentant dickhead Peter Bryan Hegseth under the bus might just be the red meat the American public would find cathartic enough to make it seem like the Democratic Party is fighting back and making headway. So we can all take our eyes off the ball, knowing we're in good hands. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01and then we'd end up with Secretary of Defense Stephen Miller. God.
SPEAKER_00Let's not think about that. We should all expect to be hearing the name Pete Heggseth quite a bit in the near future. So I assert that now is the perfect time to drill down on the topic of Pete Hegseth. In order to prevent a situation where we may be asked to contemplate Pete Heggseth later and not be able to give it the effort that Pete Hegseth merits. The current iteration of Pete Heggseth not properly dealt with in this moment becomes a more formidable Pete Heggseth, not easily dealt with in the future.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00He's only in his mid-40s, after all. As far as I can deduce, there's only three explanations for Pete Heggseth. And I don't like any of them. What's behind door number one is incompetence. They put a weekend Fox news host in charge of the most powerful military in human history because I guess they just don't know what the job is, or they don't care.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. They
SPEAKER_00figured all they needed in a Secretary of Defense was a guy who could effectively bullshit the public. Maybe.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00Door number two is they've lost touch with reality. Pete Hexeth was regularly on the Fox and Friends show discussing his main topic of expertise. What's wrong with the military? How all the rules of engagement have destroyed the warrior ethos and turned the military woke when the military should be a bunch of bloodthirsty savages that answer to nobody. And that's exactly what the president thinks, because the president experiences people on TV as esteemed colleagues, since they're important enough to merit being on TV. Trump probably listens to and considers the advice and opinions of the hosts on Fox and Friends more frequently than the people in his own cabinet, because the people on Fox and Friends don't stop talking when he starts talking to the television because he's got dementia. And people with dementia believe that the people on TV are talking to them. But Trump is the only one who believes it where it happens to be true. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01that does happen to be true, that they are in fact trying to communicate with him daily. Now
SPEAKER_00hyperbole. In 2019, Pete Hagseth used his Fox and Friends platform to repeatedly lobby Trump to pardon service members that do war crimes. Trump did so within weeks. Door number three is it's on purpose. There's a military turn, a decapitation strike. You don't fight the army, you take out the people who run it. And when you line up everything Heggseth has done, it kind of looks like a decapitation strike, just in slow motion from the inside. So let's open the doors. Dr. Craig, when you look at someone like Heggseth, do you see a guy who peaks as Secretary of Defense or a guy being built for something bigger?
SPEAKER_01That's the core question, right? Exactly like you were talking about. With Hegeseth, I can see either way. One of the things that the Trump administration and Trump himself, uh, what they love to do is they hire somebody who is grossly incompetent for an extremely important task. They don't do that for everything. Secretary of State is Marco Rubio. We've had worse secretaries of state in this country. I fucking hate Marco Rubio, but you know, he seems to be doing the job. Sometimes, though, the Trump administration picks a guy who is just so woefully inadequate for the task that their inadequacy for the task becomes the story instead of what their government office is doing now. We talk about whether he's fit to be DOD as opposed to the war in Iran. That's one way to read Hegseth, and maybe that's what he is. But at the same time, Hegzeth is a guy who has been floated by some members of the Republican Party as the next guy. He's young, he at least pretends to be fit, he takes his shirt off, he looks like a scary podcast man, or maybe somebody who's gonna make you a really good Smash Burger. That's the kind of guy that the Republican Party thinks that the American people want. And there's a certain part of the American people that do want that. He's a veteran, he's been on TV just like Trump. There's a way in which he could see his way towards running for office, and he very well might.
SPEAKER_00I think it is not just me. The whole country has avoided contemplating Pete Heggseth, partly out of embarrassment, sure, but mostly I think because of how we feel about the military. In my head, the United States military is still a pillar of uprightedness. The one institution left that still works, the adults, the guys who show up on time with their boots shine. And I know where that comes from. Plenty of it's earned. A lot of people in uniform are exactly that, disciplined, forthright, well-groomed. But a good amount of that is managed. Flyovers at football games, recruiting ads about how the military will make you the best possible man you could be. Movies, American exceptionalism, the belief that we have the best military in the history of the world. Full stop. And a belief I didn't know I had until I started thinking about Pete Hegseth. I think the US military is such a formidable institution that you could put a guy like Hegeseth in charge and it wouldn't actually matter. They'd either lift him up to a higher level or isolate him within the bureaucracy so well that he couldn't possibly do any damage, no matter how hard he tried.
SPEAKER_01That's a really good point. Part of the thing here is that like Hegeseth is in charge of an institution that is so powerful and so big that he is showing the limits of what leadership can even do. Even if he were trying to fuck up the military, like if that were his intention, he can't do it. How would he do that? You know?
SPEAKER_00That's what we think, but maybe it's not true. I still think it. That's how much respect I have for the U.S. military. And I'm a realist. I don't think I respect the US military more than most people. Yeah. I know for certain I don't respect the U.S. military as much as some people. Here's the question I couldn't let myself ask. How could such a serious organization, a giant enterprise like the U.S. military with a trillion dollar annual budget, countenance such an unserious character in a position of leadership? I think the honest answer is it couldn't. Not the old version, which means either the organization isn't as serious as I always thought, or it has failed to come up with a plan that accounted for a presidential administration actively undermining, functionally no different than an attack. Is that the way to defeat a trillion-dollar military? You can't win on weapons, so you compromise the soft targets and then you get rid of the people that are supposed to hold them accountable? You compromise the civilian leadership? Just not in an espionage way.
SPEAKER_01This has always been the sort of Russia-gate theory around Trump. As much as I bristle and question conspiracy thinking about Trump, I think that there's enough domestic reasons for him to have been elected. It's pretty clear he has some connection to this kind of shit. And that Russian institutions did try to help him be the president. That is how you would defeat the United States military by putting incompetent people in charge of it. It also discredits the institution internationally and domestically, especially the things that Heggseth is doing to the military and the things that he says about it are specifically and literally attacking the things that the United States military is good at. What the United States military is good at is logistics. And that's basically what every winning military has always been good at. Roman legionaries were not particularly better fighters than Celtic barbarians or something like that. They just had an incredibly powerful logistics machine that got them food and medicine and shelter. And then they were good at fighting too. You know, in World War II, the United States has an entire ship in the Pacific whose only purpose is to produce ice cream to make soldiers happy.
SPEAKER_00I didn't know that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, uh during World War II at Thanksgiving, the United States military gives as many soldiers as possible actual turkey dinners with cranberry sauce. During the Iraq War, the United States military has Xboxes because they want to make soldiers happy because morale and logistics are how you win a war. Whereas Hegseth thinks that the United States military is good because we're Spartans and we don't like material comforts. We're just good warriors. But it's the opposite. It's the exact opposite. The United States military is really good because it's cushier than other militaries. That's what makes us good at it. Because it's nicer to be a soldier in the US military than it is to be a soldier in another military.
SPEAKER_00In the recent news, there's been talk of this ship out in Iran that was on a deployment for eight months when she'd only been out for six months. People were jumping off the ship trying to kill themselves.
SPEAKER_01I think it's the Abraham Lincoln.
SPEAKER_00That's what it was, the USS Abraham Lincoln. And they showed, they kept showing pictures of the food. And the food did not look good at all.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00Not a great recruiting tool for the US military.
SPEAKER_01No. The whole point of the institution, the reason that it works, is that it is a better life for you right now if you are in poverty, and then a promise of a middle class life afterwards. That is what the institution is domestically. It used to be the most robust welfare system that the United States had. It was a way to get a middle class life. You get low interest loans and you get money to go to college and all sorts of shit, right? That's what the military is for. What Heggseth is trying to do is to make it essentially a fight club, an athletic club, like a neo-Nazi street brawlers thing. That is a way forward for it as a domestic power, but that's not what the United States military does.
SPEAKER_00Maybe that's the thing we've been avoiding, not Pete Hagzath, but the possibility that he's being used as a weapon to undermine our military in plain sight, but it looks so much like incompetence that nobody can quite tell whether the element of intentionality is present or not. Dr. Craig, is Pete Hagsat the inevitable outcome of American exceptionalism? Does it all build towards this?
SPEAKER_01Oh my god. Yeah, I think that there's a way that how the United States talks about success and masculinity and are just gross misunderstanding of what US power is. We have movies, we have shows, we have fucking Top Gun, and we have Top Gun Maverick, and they're all about glorious men achieving incredible levels of violence spectacularly. Whereas what beat the Nazis was the Soviet Union, and then secondarily the fact that the United States had the largest economy on the planet. That's the reason that the United States is so good at all these things. We have the biggest economy, so we have the best machines, and we have a good logistics system. That's how we win. I think you're right. Heggseth is that image of the military coming home to roost and confronting the reality of the military, which is something entirely different. The actual military is an enormous international bureaucracy. And if you try to remake it in the image that the bureaucracy presents itself with, you know, this like perfect warrior ethos, the best man that you can be, it's gonna fuck itself over. It's gonna fuck itself up. And then, of course, there's the classic this guy's a perfect example of a fail son. You know, he's just a guy who's failed upward his entire life, gotten more and more and more powerful, the more and more fucked he is.
SPEAKER_00In the last year, the Pentagon's own inspector general found Pete Hegseth had shared strike details in a signal chat that included a journalist by accident, and in a second chat with his wife and his brother. Heggseth declined to be interviewed and handed over only a handful of his messages. Eventually, the accountability fell on National Security Advisor Mike Walls, who was removed from the White House and reassigned, alongside his top deputy, and a group of mid-level Pentagon aides ousted during a subsequent leak investigation. Nearly two dozen generals and admirals have been fired or pushed out under Pete Heggs. He's made a 20% reduction in four-star generals, retired them early. No plans to fill the position. He's asking for one and a half trillion dollars in budget this year, the biggest jump in defense spending since the Korean War. And this week, the vote, the tomb, and the stop quoting laws to men with sores. He quoted Pompeii, a Roman general who got his head cut off a few years later. You picked the decapitation guy, Pete. It doesn't really matter which door it is, incompetence, delusion, or intent. The effects are the same. A weaker military run by a man who answers to one person and who wants to be around for 20 more years. For a long time I didn't look at that because it felt disrespectful to the troops, to the veterans, but it's the opposite. The most important thing we can do for the people serving right now, the veterans of the next 20 years, is to look hard at the man running the military. Scrutinizing the military isn't disrespectful to veterans. It's how you protect the future ones. And in January, Congress finally gets a chance to contemplate Pete Heggshead. I hope they do a better job of it than I did. Stare into the abyss with friends, the Autocratic Despair Podcast with Nick Mortensen and Dr. Craig Johnson. And don't forget Dr. Craig's other podcast, 15 minutes of fascism, available wherever you get your podcast.